HOW MANY KIDS DID EACH SISTER HAVE???

[wiccarules]

I have watched the series finale' three or four times now and each time I watch it I get a bit more confused. When they are writing in the Book of Shadows as to what has happened now and in the future, Phoebe has two daughters and is in labor for her third so she has three daughters, then Paige writes and it shows that she has one son and twin daughters, so she has three kids. Then Piper writes and she talks about her not having P3 anymore but she has her own restaurant and Leo is a teacher at magic school. At one point it shows her giving out lunches to three kids, two boys and a girl, but she never says that she got the daughter she saw in the future. It shows Wyatt and Chris as they are older making a potion so you know she had both of them. Then at the very end when old Leo and Piper walk up the stairs and her granddaughter is reading the Book of Shadows it shows all the pictures on the wall and it has a picture of Grams, one of Piper and Patty (her mother) it shows Wyatt alone as a baby, Wyatt and Chris as babies, it has a picture of Leo holding babies Wyatt and Chris and Wyatt and Chris together as adults, but not one picture of a daughter. It also has a picture of all three sisters. So did she or didn't she get her daughter???I'm just so confused. Does anyone know if she got her daughter or did she end up only having two kids?? By the way sorry this is so long.

[Andi]

we aren't ever going to know for sure, but I think each sister had 2. and as for the pictures, its probably because those were flashback of pics of times we had seen over the years of charmed, and there was no daughter yet, so we didnt' see that

[wiccarules]

Andi, was nice of you to reply to my question. I do know that Phoebe and Paige both had three kids, Paige had a son and twin girls and Phoebe had three daughters. That much I do know, they showed it in the season finale'. But they never said how many Piper had. Of course everyone knows she had the two boys, Wyatt and Chris but they never said if she got her daughter. There has been a big debate about it on different sites most people think she got her daughter because it shows her giving lunches to three kids. But I would think if she got her daughter they would have had a picture of her on the stairs like they did everyone else. In all the pictures the only kids you see are Wyatt and Chris as babies and the one picture of the two of them grown up and Leo holding both boys. You would think if she got her daughter they would have had her picture on the stairs as well. But I guess your right that we'll never know for sure.

[saskia]

I think they didn't have a 'face' (if you know what i mean) for Piper and Leo's third child, but we won't know for sure, as you said... Too bad, because i really would have wanna know... In the book The Warren Witches it shows that Paige had one kid or grandchild called Pandora. Need to read that story again, to refresh my memory!

[Andi]

all of the pictures on the wall were of photos of times we had seen on the show. since the daughter was not born during the show, she was not there, as phoebe and paiges kids werent. dont you think they would have had a picture up there too? that was simply set up by the producers for one last stroll down memory lane

[Sarah Ann]

That little girl was Piper's daughter. They never said it in the episode, but according to the official script, she was Piper's daughter and was in fact named Melinda! I think they just didn't show her in the pics because that was their one last time looking back at the show. And remember, they showed only a few specific pics on the wall on purpose, there were so many pics on the wall but they only zoomed in on a few, the others could have very easily been other family members or the kids at different ages and occasions

[saskia]

^ i so like that thought of imagening those other kids/family members pictures hanging there too!

[melinda]

It was in fact Melinda yes. The actress portraying her is named Kathleen Teresa Scott

www.imdb.com/name/nm2656319/

A parent added a resume for her stating . If A parent didn't know the role their daughter had who would?

[saskia]

Hmm, thanks for sharing this! I didn't know this!

[~Mistic*Prue~]

Im soo lost is she the girl that was with older Piper cause if so she could have been any one of the grandkids of the sisters or a great grandkid of one of there kids with the name Melinda man ill have to go back and watch it over and over...Oh well ill let you know what i think..lol.

[Sarah Ann]

Apr 17, 2008 0:54:20 GMT ~Mistic*Prue~ said:

Im soo lost is she the girl that was with older Piper cause if so she could have been any one of the grandkids of the sisters or a great grandkid of one of there kids with the name Melinda man ill have to go back and watch it over and over...Oh well ill let you know what i think..lol.

Melinda was the little girl we saw Piper give a lunch box too. Her Chris and Wyatt were all going off to school so she was Piper's daughter. The little girl with old Piper was a grandchild (I believe she called Piper "grandma" but its been too long since I have seen it to know for sure).

[~Mistic*Prue~]

OK i got lost i thought it was the other girl in the chair with Piper but i do know they show all the sisters with three kids how many Chris,Wyatt and all the others we will never know.

[saskia]

You mean almost the last part of Forever Charmed? When old Piper is reading, that kid is a grandchild of Piper & Leo.

[Sarah Ann]

Yep, yep, of course she called her "Grandmama" and given Piper's age then I think it is more likely that that was her and Leo's great-granddaughter (I think her name is supposed to be Prudence). Especially when you compare her in age to Matthew their grandson who Leo was teaching at magic school. Leo then was much younger than he was with the little girl at the end. I hope that made sense...