|
Post by Dianna on Jan 3, 2002 23:18:09 GMT
Ok guys,whos better??? i can't vote because i haven't seen a single eppy of Charmed season 4 so it wouldn't be fair,i know ppl in the US are already(almost) half way through so the question is mainly to them...
|
|
|
Post by Piperfreak2001 on Jan 21, 2002 16:10:35 GMT
No offence to Shannen fans but Rose is A LOT better than Shannen!! Her character is much better then Prue's hostility and harshness! ROSE RULES!! PS: I'm from New York so I've seen all of the season 4 eppis so far!!
|
|
|
Post by Holly_Halliwell on Feb 28, 2002 10:59:28 GMT
Hum I like the both but Shannen was the best in Prue but Paige is...hum...ok ! lol
|
|
|
Post by PiperFreezeMe on Mar 31, 2002 10:37:17 GMT
Shannen is an amazing actress, and Rose brings somethign great to charmed which I love, so over all Shanne is a better actress and I loved her in Charmed, but I think I like charmed better with Rose, come on Di you've seen lots of it now, so who'dya choose?
|
|
|
Post by Dianna on May 22, 2002 21:25:05 GMT
Now that i have seen as far as the 3 faces of phoebe i'd have to say that i have alot of respect for Rose and shes very talented and sweet, but i like Shannen best!
|
|
|
Post by Angel4Charmed3 on Jun 22, 2002 2:42:09 GMT
Personally i like Rose/Paige better. I used to like Prue/Shannen until I found out about her diva attitude.
|
|
|
Post by 3isthemagicnumber on Jul 11, 2002 22:06:08 GMT
Thats what totally did it for me too - i now prefer rose. I used to think it wuld never be the same without shannen, but i much prefer paige's sweet and calm nature to prue's serious and moody one! But still, i ahve respect for both actresses and im glad prue was there for 3 seasons. Now im happy that its paige now and wouldnt want to change anything!
|
|
|
Post by Angel4Charmed3 on Jul 17, 2002 14:46:21 GMT
i know i posted be4 but that was my best friend. So now im going to vote.
Well, I really can't choose. I mean when Prue/Shannen left, I started to get used to Paige/Rose. But then I started watching some of the old episodes with Prue in them and I started to miss her. I used to record the episodes, but I don't anymore. It's because I have a screwed up T.V.
|
|
Piper
Holly Wanna Be
Posts: 57
|
Post by Piper on Sept 12, 2002 0:43:14 GMT
[glow=purple,2,300]hee hee well I acualy have a wierd story. Ok well it's not wierd actualy but I thought i'd just say it. I used to be obcessed with rose mcgowan when I started to become obcessed with the movie scream. But then she was just never really in any movies so I kinda forgot about her. Then I became obcessed with Charmed. I never really liked Prue. But I didn't want her replaced because I though they would pick someone stupid and it would ruin the show. But then I heard about Rose McGowan joining the show. I totaly couldn't believe it. I think she is so great on the show. I love all the sisters evenly so I don't have a fave I wish I did. I also saw this rose mcgowan interview. I think it was on jay leno. And it turns out rose mcgowan has been a huge fan of the show just like us! That made me pretty happy to know that my idol loved something that was practicaly my life. Sorry if I rambled hee hee i'm a lil bored[/glow]
|
|
|
Post by Angel4Charmed3 on Sept 12, 2002 7:11:21 GMT
No, you weren't rambling. That's some story. It's cool though. Ciao, :-*Leah
|
|
|
Post by piperpaigephoebe on Dec 23, 2002 5:43:17 GMT
I like both Shannen and Rose. It is kind of hard to say either or, but Shannen did spice up the show a little. Now that more episodes are coming out with Rose, she has almost made it past Shannen. That is my opinion.
|
|
|
Post by Angel4Charmed3 on Dec 30, 2002 5:13:52 GMT
[glow=violet,2,300]You are wise and noble young one. LOL. Ciao, :-*Leah [/glow]
|
|
|
Post by Dianna on Jan 14, 2003 0:44:57 GMT
I'm actually used to Rose now, she is cool but Shannen has that little something more...
|
|
|
Post by Angel4Charmed3 on Jan 19, 2003 18:30:40 GMT
[glow=violet,2,300]Yeah.... :ufo: Ciao, Leah [/glow]
|
|
|
Post by PiperLeoP3 on Jan 30, 2003 0:32:32 GMT
I kinda like Prue a tad bit more because she was a track more and everything. Paige just jacks off and everything. Well Phoebe DID to but thats another story she was younger nd everything. i just don't like Paige's additude.
|
|