|
Post by charmed98 on Sept 4, 2008 15:09:43 GMT
I know we are all upset that Shannen left the show but it was a alot better with her on it. The chemistry that Shannen, Holly and Alyssa had is unbelievable. I just hate that it ended. dont make me laugh the show was a let down when Prue was in it, Paige revived the show, the show is hands down better with Paige in it Don't make me laugh! The show was already a hit with Prue. Many fans (myself included) lost interest in the show when Prue left, and the quality of the show went down tremendously. It became silly, too much fluff, too much about Phoebe's breast and sexy or skimpy outfits. The depth of the show and the chemistry was gone once Prue left. The show went from being an excellent mixture of suspense, adventure, comedy, drama to a silly, too much fluff, sex in the city type of show.
|
|
|
Post by charmed98 on Sept 4, 2008 15:11:42 GMT
i chose the second set of charmed ones because they accomplished more and had the best chemistry as sisters which was just not there with the first set of charmed ones Not there? ? Holly had awesome chemistry with Alyssa and Shannen, who was her best friend for years in real-life. Alyssa, Shannen, and Holly all had excellent chemistry together. That's why the show was a hit in the first place.
|
|
|
Post by charmed98 on Sept 4, 2008 15:17:27 GMT
prue is wayy 2 perfect. She puts in a full day at work, kicks demon a$$ and still has enough time 4 a personal life. but i heard that she isnt 2 perfect off stage if u know wat i mean. fighting with alyssa. if i were alyssa i would have been kicked her a$$... no offence 2 shannon(LOL)... i wonder why she didnt try 2 talk 2 holly like that??? Actually, Prue quit her job in the middle of Season 2. However, the same thing can be said of Piper, Phoebe, and Paige. They put in a full day at work, kick demon a$$, and still have enough time for a personal life. Heck, Piper even juggled being a wife, witch, sister, and mother. Lots, of women in real-life can put in a full day at work, have a part-time job (kicking demon ass was a part time job for the Charmed Ones), and still have enough time for a personal life. That's nothing great or hard to do! Plus, Prue had her sisters, the Power of 3, and Leo to help her. She wasn't alone. Also, this is a supernatural, fictional television show, so there could be a lot of things that would be considered too perfect or unreal. It is a magical show, afterall.
|
|
|
Post by charmed98 on Sept 4, 2008 15:28:39 GMT
I go with Piper, Phoebe and Paige. Due to my opinion, i think Prue was a little stuck up...It was like she was always picking on the other ones (specially on Phoebe), always knowing things better In that case, Piper picked on Paige and always acted like Paige was not good enough. That's why Paige was always trying to prove herself. As for prue always knowing things better, well, the older siblings probably do know things better, but there were plenty of times when Phoebe and Piper knew things better as well during the Prue years. Prue never "picked" on her sisters. Prue and Piper never even argued. Prue and Piper were the closest sisters. Prue and Phoebe argued a few times. Phoebe was always borrowing Prue's clothes, computer, and car. Prue had to support Phoebe, who was a grown, healthy woman, who was capable of working, but didn't. Besides, before Phoebe moved back in with Prue and Piper, Phoebe had a reputation of being very wild, hanging with a bad crowd (Hyde School Reunion, Season 6), always getting into trouble, and shoplifting (Pre-witched - Season 3). I can't really blame Prue for wanting better for Phoebe. You have to look at it from both point of views, not just Phoebe's. Phoebe was freeloading off of Prue and Piper. Prue wanted better for her sister, and there's nothing wrong with that. You make it sound like Phoebe was totally innocent. Prue always would tell Phoebe how smart she was, and even got Phoebe a job at her employment at Buckland's. Prue let her borrow her clothes for interviews and gave her a ride to Buckland's every morning. Prue was not "stuck up" at all. She was always helping her sisters and others, and Prue would be the first sister to help YOU or I. In that case, Phoebe was being lazy and taking advantage of her sisters. Besides, siblings and friends pick on each other all the time. It's no big deal! It's not like Prue cursed her out and kicked her out on the street. In that case, Piper picked on Phoebe as well, and Phoebe picked on Piper. Phoebe even tried to steal Leo away from Piper, even though she knew that Piper really liked Leo. Phoebe even admitted that the only reason she wanted Leo was because Piper wanted him in the episode "The truth is out....and it hurts." It's funny how anything Prue does is always criticized, but when the other sisters do something just as bad or worse, it's overlooked. Also, Phoebe constantly had a attitude with Paige about Cole right before she married him and afterwards as well. She yelled at Paige for getting the wrong dress before the wedding, and she didn't care how Cole rudely treated or talked to Paige or her sisters. She also got an attitude with Paige about orbing in hers and Cole's apartment. And Piper was alway barking orders at Paige. Strange how Piper being bossy or picking on her sisters is just overlooked, yet Prue is always criticied for it.
|
|
|
Post by charmed98 on Sept 4, 2008 16:18:44 GMT
And to anwer the question.......the ORIGINAL Charmed Ones were the best! They had better chemistry together. Shannen, Holly, and Alyssa all had outstanding chemistry together. Shannen and Holly had been best friends for years way before they did Charmed, and it showed.
Prue and Piper were best as the older sisters, and Phoebe was perfect as the streetwise, free-spirited, and, petite, and adorable baby sister. Plus, Shannen, Alyssa, and Holly all looked like sisters. The sisterly bond was a lot better. I liked that the sisters all shared history and had the same parents. Paige was always like an outsider because she didn't share history with them and she had a different father. I loved when the Prue, Piper, and Phoebe were nostalgic and would say, like, remember when we were little and at summer camp, and we all pledged to be best friends as well as sisters.......or when Piper told Prue that she was scared of water, that's why she never took swimming lessons with them (meaning her and Phoebe). I love that shared history and bond as sister.
Also, Paige was too tall to be the baby sister. I liked how Prue was the big sister and a little taller than Phoebe and Piper. Paige looked older than Phoebe, particularly since she was taller. Plus, Paige being pale made her kinda stand out from the sisters. Prue, Piper and Phoebe blended in better and physically looked more like sisters.
Plus, Prue is Piper's favorite, and I miss Piper having her big sister around.
|
|
|
Post by charmed98 on Sept 4, 2008 16:24:18 GMT
i say Paige, Phoebe and Piper!!! I heard Shannnon is so nawt nice!!! It's not about the real actresses. Shannen is Holly's best friend in real life. That has nothing to do with the characters on Charmed. Plus, Shannen got Holly the job on Charmed, so she can't be too bad, if she did that for Holly, and she's Holly's best friend. Besides, we don't know any of the actresses personally. I wouldn't go by what I heard. Shannen could be the nicest actress on Charmed or in Hollywood. Just because you haven't heard about the other Charmed actresses doesn't mean they're nice or perfect angels. The media seems more interested in Shannen and likes to twist and overexaggerate a lot. Even Holly said that neither Shannen or Alyssa were angels.
|
|
|
Post by charmed98 on Sept 4, 2008 16:29:32 GMT
I go with Piper, Phoebe and Paige. Due to my With Paige around the characters developed more i think, they've grown up alot more... The characters already had developed with Prue on the show. Prue, Phoebe, and Piper were all different during the second and third season than they were from the first. The development would have happened anyways, as the show went on, with Prue or Paige.
|
|
|
Post by charmed98 on Sept 4, 2008 16:32:18 GMT
it's hard for me to pick cause i love them both so i pick both cause they all are cool but have to admit the second one is cool cause paige is cool cause since she's half whitelighter cause it is cool to be half witch and half whitelighter it's awsome but i do love both cause either way piper was still in it and cause as long as got to see them in action useing their powers to get those nasty evil demons is always fun to watch I didn't like one of the Charmed Ones being half whitelighter. It became too redundant and repetitive, since Leo was already a whitelighter, and the kids were half whitelighters. It made the show more about whitelighters than witches.
|
|
|
Post by charmed98 on Sept 4, 2008 16:33:14 GMT
I dont like Shannon.... I like it better with Paige..... Shannen is Holly's best friend, and got her the job on Charmed. Holly defended Shannen when she was fired from the show.
|
|
|
Post by oliviastem on Oct 19, 2008 19:48:55 GMT
|
|
|
Post by irena on Oct 20, 2008 11:32:00 GMT
I like both and chemistry was some by me on all over the 8 season.
|
|
|
Post by hopious on Nov 28, 2008 2:43:20 GMT
I chose the first set with Prue, I just like Shannen more than Rose, even though I think that they're both great actresses.
|
|
Izabella
A Major Holly Fan
I am being stalked by a psycho killer and I hide in the shower?!
Posts: 333
|
Post by Izabella on Feb 11, 2009 13:26:54 GMT
I chose the second set of Charmed Ones . I like Shannen and I like her role in Charmed and Beverly Hills 90210 but I really like Charmed more with Piper, Phoebe and Paige. My favourite character is Piper and although I think she's very good as a middle sister I think she was perfect as the oldest. Imo in the first 3 seasons Prue's character was mainly in the center of everything and a lot of episodes was about her. And though in next seasons there was many episodes about Phoebe and Paige I think that script writers gave Piper much more attention than earlier . I think during first three seasons she was a little bit in the shadow of Prue (if you now what I mean, cause I don't know the right expression for it . I also love the development of Piper's character after Prue's death - she had to fit in the role of the oldest sister and for me she did great. Also Piper could've become the most powerful witch . She became stronger and joined features of the 'old Piper' with some that she evolved as the oldest sister. I really can't imagine how the show would look like if Prue hadn't die and now I also cannot imagine different Piper .
|
|
rukky
New Holly Fan
Posts: 1
|
Post by rukky on Oct 29, 2009 14:53:26 GMT
All three of them are awesome.They are all great.Piper is da bomb,Phoebe is da hottest while Paige is da sexiest.The girls are really wondrful.
|
|
|
Post by irena on Oct 29, 2009 19:34:39 GMT
Steel I think this is unfair compariation. They are all five of them great.
|
|